
News & Insights
The Superfan Economy Is Being Tested

"If superfans are the music industry's most valuable customers, how much more can they be asked to pay?"
For most of the past decade, the music industry grew by finding new listeners. Streaming brought hundreds of millions of people into paid subscriptions. That phase is maturing, and growth now depends more on earning more from the fans the industry already has.
The 2026 Goldman Sachs Music in the Air report expects future growth to come from regular streaming price rises, spending by superfans and live music, rather than from user numbers alone. The price rises are already happening. In February 2026, Spotify raised its US Premium price from $11.99 to $12.99 a month, and Goldman Sachs expects streaming services to keep raising prices every 12 to 24 months.
At the centre of this are superfans. According to Luminate, 20% of US music listeners are superfans, meaning they engage with artists in five or more ways, from going to shows to buying merch or joining fan clubs. Luminate's research found they spend an average of $113 a month on live music, 66% more than the average listener.
Music is also only one part of a much wider fan economy. Deloitte found that around 80% of US consumers see themselves as fans of at least one category, from music and sport to gaming, film and TV.
[Source: Goldman Sachs, Bloomberg, Luminate, Deloitte]
Three price rises, one fan
Mark Mulligan, founder of MIDiA Research, a firm that analyses the music business for record labels and streaming services, has warned that fans are being asked for more money from three directions at once: higher streaming prices, more merchandise and vinyl from artists and labels, and higher ticket prices from live companies. Each part of the industry, he argues, treats the same fan as its own separate customer.
Ticket prices show how far one of those levers has already moved. According to Pollstar, the average ticket for the world's top 100 tours rose from $96.17 in 2019 to $132.62 in 2025, an increase of around 38%.
[Source: MIDiA Research, Pollstar]
Fans are still paying, but the base isn’t growing
So far, fans are absorbing these increases. Across entertainment, 73% of US consumers told Deloitte they are frustrated that the services they subscribe to keep raising prices.
In live music, however, price is putting fewer fans off. Luminate's Live Music 2026 report found that the share of Gen Z concertgoers who say ticket prices stop them going to more shows fell from 75% to 57% between early 2024 and early 2026. Over a similar period, the share of music listeners rating concerts as good or great value rose from 73% to 78%. Fans appear willing to pay more when the experience feels worth it.
But the audience is not growing at the same pace. Luminate found that US concert attendance has held steady since it peaked in 2023, while the share of Gen Z concertgoers going to two shows a year rose from 29% to 37%. In 2025, the number of tickets sold for the world's top 100 tours fell 3.7%, according to Pollstar, even as the average show earned more.
This suggests more of the industry's growth is coming from the same committed fans paying more and showing up more often. That is a strength while it lasts, and a risk if that group starts to pull back.
Where is fandom heading?
There are already signs of competition for the same budget. Luminate found that in early 2026, Gen Z men spent twice as much on video games as on live music events. At the same time, fans appear willing to give more when the relationship feels direct. Goldman Sachs found that close to half of fans pay more than the minimum price when artists sell to them directly through pay-what-you-want storefronts.
The major labels are already moving in this direction. Universal Music Group has partnered with and invested in fan platforms including Weverse and Stationhead, while Sony Music and Warner Music have set up their own direct-to-fan divisions.
The difference is between relying on fans to accept higher prices and giving them a reason to choose to spend more. As Mulligan puts it, "you cannot harvest fandom if you are not also nurturing it."
[Source: Goldman Sachs, MIDiA Research]
La Royale Group perspective
Superfans have become central to the music industry's growth plans, and for a good reason - they spend more and show up more often than any other part of the audience. Music offers the clearest example, but the same question applies wherever fandom is being turned into revenue, from sport to gaming.
From our perspective, the risk lies in treating that loyalty as something to draw on, rather than something to build. Price rises across streaming, tickets and merchandise may lift revenue in the short term, but they depend on the goodwill of a relatively small group of people.
For investors, revenue per fan is only part of the picture. More telling may be whether fans are spending because they choose to. The businesses best placed may be those that keep fans connected between the moments they pay for, giving them ways to take part and share the experience with others, rather than simply charging them more.